Critical Mass – Edmonton, AB ’09 from Sheldon Smart on Vimeo.
Happy Monday morning to you all!
For a while I’ve said that I wasn’t sure Critical Mass was a good idea. The way I saw it, cyclist were picking one Friday each month during rush hour to take to the streets en mass and hold up traffic; I didn’t see how this would exactly endear cyclists in the hearts of motorists. So, last Friday I took part in Edmonton’s Critical Mass to see for myself what it was about. I didn’t know what to expect: peaceful celebration of a growing bicycle and commuter culture, or blatant bone-head protest toward motorists. Were we out there to just slow Friday afternoon traffic and frustrate them? Were motorists going to be hostile as we rode through downtown? I was a little nervous about it, but I figured it would probably be somewhere in between.
I’d been told the ride was set for 5:30pm at City Hall, so I showed up a bit early. When I first rolled up, there might have been 6 riders there, me included. I was expecting big numbers for some reason. I guess the photos I’d seen of CMs in other cities had me thinking this would be a some kind of massive gathering – it sure didn’t look like that was going to be the case here. By 5:30 though, the group had swelled and I’d hazard a guess that 50 riders were there. We didn’t leave right on time. People kind of just stood around and chatted for while and more and more riders kept showing up. By 6 o’clock there were probably around 120 riders from all rides of life: roadies, mountain bikers, cruisers, fixies, you name it. It was interesting to see the types and the age of riders vary so much – it really was a random smattering, so there was no way that someone couldn’t fit in.
Before we rolled out some basic instructions/rules were given about how the group needed to act and behave – nothing punitive at all, just things like, for safety we wanted to ride in two lanes whenever possible, and once the group starts to cross an intersection we wanted to continue through until the last rider, even if the lights have turned red. The goal was to move as one unit.
We circled City Hall and headed west down Jasper Ave at about 10km/h, then swung east on 109st across the High Level bridge and then east down Whyte Ave to 99st where we turned north and headed to the gazebo by the bus barns. All in all, I’d say this was about 10-12 kms in total distance.
This is the part I was most curious about – what was the public and motorist response going to be? Well, on the whole, it was incredibly positive. Sure there were one or two less than pleasant things uttered in our direction, but the vast, vast majority of people we passed, pedestrian or motorist alike, smiled and waved and even cheered as we rode by. Now, I wasn’t riding right on the back end of the pack where the motorist might have been most inconvenienced so I can’t say what that scene was like back there, but from where I was and from what I saw, it was nothin’ but love, man. Nothin’ but love…
The verdict is, I’ll take part again, for sure. And, I’d recommend you do the same if you’ve never done so. This wasn’t an anarchist’s bicycle march on Capital Hill like some people think; this was a really well run, peaceful, well meaning and well received statement that bikes are not blocking traffic, they are traffic. Good times, indeed and hats off to the CM faithful. Hope to see you all again soon.






Glad to see you’re one of the converted.
Thanks for the vid, missed the ride, had to work late. ;)
Okay, what is Critical Mass trying to prove anyway? From my perspective it is a way to show you are better than everyone else.
I am very thankful I was able to turn onto 109th St. right before the mass of bicycles. It scares me that apparently traffic lights don’t apply to you. But what really annoys me is that you are taking up both lanes of traffic. Now, everyone in traffic has the right to be rude and make people hate them, but if your point is to make people like bicycles, shouldn’t you follow the “Slow traffic keep right” policy? You are acting just like a train that stops at a railway crossing for a long period. I don’t like them either.
I am all for better support for bicycles, and I would like it if Edmonton was a more bicycle friendly city; it certainly needs bike lanes and more trails. Driver education would also help. But whenever a protester is inconveniencing me for the sake of a protest, it just makes me want to do the opposite.
I probably sound like a troll, but that is not my intent. This is just the opinion of someone who drives a car.
hey i drive a car too and don`t have that opinion. Sometimes driving can really go to people`s heads though and make them think they`re `better than everyone else` too, as you say. For one thing, better and worse doesn`t exist! :) And it`s healthy to turn things around once in a while. As he stated here, the point is to show that bicycles are not obstructing traffic — they are traffic. Do you get it now? Or are you still preoccupied with speed ….
“`Now, everyone in traffic has the right to be rude and make people hate them, but if your point is to make people like bicycles, shouldn’t you follow the “Slow traffic keep right” policy?“
People don`t `make` eachother hate, dislike, or even like them. You don`t dislike trains because of THEM, you dislike trains because of YOU. That feeling is in you and no one is out there `making people hate them`….if you have hate it`s yours so take responsibility instead of blame others.
I don`t consider CM as cyclists `trying to make people like them`…yes it`s good publicity for bikes but it`s also to say `this is how we like to travel, please accept it`….there`s a lot of different rhythms to flow by. Just go with the flow. Maybe you would like CM so try it.
Speed kills.
This conversation exemplifies why I struggle with the point of the Critical Mass… I’m all for the rationale behind it (from my understanding, an attempt to raise awareness for cycling and assert them as a vehicle that belongs in traffic as well), but as @cardriver points out, from a drivers position all it serves is to frustrate.
With that said, I definitely think @g is hitting the heart of the matter by touching on a drivers preoccupation with speed and ‘getting through traffic’, but I’m unsure how a Critical Mass does anything to help this situation – Again, many times all it does is aggravate already hurried drivers.
I think the problem lies in the fact that to anybody outside of a CM there is absolutely no context (to my knowledge)… To a driver, it’s probably something to the effect of “Oh… There must be some sort of cycling event… Cool… I gotta to get home, hope it wraps up soon and they get the heck out of my way.”
I’m unsure as to how to get the context of a CM out there, perhaps banners, badges, or jerseys that the cyclists wear, pointing to a website for drivers to find out more information, but to @cardrivers point, taking up both lanes does less to prove a point, and more to piss drivers off. Shouldn’t the riders in a CM exemplify commuters best practices?
The sad thing is that when it come to the road, cars own it, whether cyclists like it or not. 19lbs of aluminum vs. 1000lbs of warm Detroit steel? We both know who’s winning that battle.
I understand the need to get out there and ruffle some drivers feathers, and I also understand the need to make it happen during times that maximize exposure and impact (ie. high traffic times), but I think it needs to be done in the most courteous manner possible to help raise awareness, while keeping a drivers impression of cyclists untainted and potentially even improving it.
Am I just being naive?
Great video Sheldon, it looked like a fun time and even I would like to participate. However, being a strong supporter of the cycling community, I have to question the mindset of the persons organizing the ride. Doing the CM rides in a confrontational way with the common motorist and in violation of the traffic rules will only turn people against the CM group.
In my humble opinion, there are two ways to conduct this worthy ride that would make it an acceptable, respected event.
#1 – Treat it as an awareness campaign. (Don’t treat it as a protest) Get a proper parade permit from the City of Edmonton and use the entire street if you like.
#2 – Again, treat it as an awareness campaign and not a protest. Do not bother with a proper parade permit. Invite cyclists to participate, however, be what cyclists are expected to be, obey the traffic laws but do it in large numbers.
My message to CM. I am with you. I encourage you to convince city governments to widen streets to accomodate cyclists and make cities friendly to motorists and safe for cyclists. I know from experience that Edmontons roadways are not safe for cyclists but city council is working on it. If you become confrontational, not only will I no longer wish to participate in your ride, you will also lose my support.
Just ran across the Edmonton Poet Laureat’s (Roland Pemberton, aka. Cadence Weapon) first reading and found it interestingly à propros and timely for this post:
Audio slideshow here »
Full poem here »
CM’s are a form of cycling demonstration which I find do not do ANYTHING for cycling, in viewing the video I see numerous cyclists without helmets and many courier types who generally do not obey ANY rules of the road. These type of “cyclists” give cyclists a bad view in the eyes of cars which they are trying to impress.
@Tim,
You might be right – I wondered about that at the time because I felt out of place wearing a helmet. That and I was one of the only dorks in spandex… :-/